Subscribe Via Web Feed Subscribe with Google Add to My Yahoo! Subscribe with Bloglines Add to netvibes Subscribe with Live.com

« Goodbye Froogle, Hello Google Product Search! | Main | QueryCAT - Search FAQs »

Apr. 18, 2007 at 9:41pm Eastern by Danny Sullivan

American Blinds Suit Against Google Over Trademarks To Go To Trial

Judge won't dismiss Google trademark suit from Reuters reports that the long-standing lawsuit over keywords linked to trademarked terms filed by American Blinds against Google will continue to trial. Google's request for summary judgment has been denied. Google's won in two similar suits within the US. Courtesy of Gary Price, you can get a copy of the ruling here (PDF format).

Like The Story? Vote For It On Yahoo Buzz!
Subscribe To Our Daily Search News Recap!
Your Email:
Send me the monthly search newsletter too! (Learn more about our newsletters and feeds)
Subscribe To Our Search Feed!
Subscribe Via Web FeedSubscribe with GoogleAdd to My Yahoo!Subscribe with BloglinesAdd to netvibes
Subscribe with Live.comSubscribe in NewsGator OnlineSubscribe in RojoAdd to My AOL
Share & Bookmark This Story!
By Danny Sullivan Permalink Jump To Comments See Related Stories In: Google: AdWords, Google: Legal, Legal: Trademarks



Reader Comments

The funny thing is that American Blinds is bidding on competitors terms, see url below. If they are so against it, why are they doing it?
http://www.thesemzone.com/2007/04/end-of-googles-trademark-lawsuits.html

Comment by Shilly [TypeKey Profile Page] | April 22, 2007 10:31 AM

When Google loses this or an upcoming trademark lawsuit, they will be impacted, but still very profitable. The majority of Adwords revenue comes from advertising on generic phrases like “window blinds” versus trademarks like “American Blind.”

Incidentally, some companies decide not to implement the current trademark policy because they may not have a vested interest in a reseller market, this choice should continue to be left to the trademark holder. The auto industry is a good example, and Ford does not implement the trademark policy on the trademarked phrase “used Ford F150″ because they encourage dealerships and aggregators to handle the used vehicle market.

What eventually will happen in the U.S. and Canada, and has already taken place in Europe, is that search engines will be required by law to completely prevent unauthorized parties from even placing ads on federally protected trademarks.

The real issue here is how “generic” can a phrase be to be allowed trademark status. Let’s look at the company, Discount Tire. People don’t normally search for “discount tire” unless they are looking for the company, Discount Tire. The generic phrase people tend to search for is “discount tires” with an ’s.’

This is where things can get heated. How does the USPTO determine if a phrase is too generic to be trademarked?

...frequently asked questions about the Google Lawsuit

Search:

Search Marketing Expo

Save the date for:
SMX Madrid (in Spanish, May 20-21)
SMX Advanced - Seattle, WA (June 3-4) Register today! Early bird rate expires May 9!
SMX Local & Mobile - San Francisco, CA (July 24-25) (July 24-25) Pre-agenda rate expires May 2. Get the lowest rate by registering now.
SMX East - NYC - (Oct. 6-8)
SMX London - November 4 & 5, 2008

Search Marketing Now

Learn more about search marketing through free online webcasts and webinars from our sister site Search Marketing Now.

Upcoming Webcasts:

Most Recent News Posts

About Search Engine Land

Stay Updated!

Get Our Search Newsletters:
Email:
Daily Monthly

Get Our Search Feed:
Subscribe Via Web FeedSubscribe with Google
Add to My Yahoo!Subscribe with Bloglines
Add to netvibesSubscribe with Live.com
Subscribe in NewsGator OnlineSubscribe in Rojo
Add to My AOL
More About Our Feeds & Newsletters

Add to Technorati Favorites

Track Us Socially:
Facebook: Our Search News App
Facebook: Search Engine Land Page
Facebook: Search Engine Land Group
Flickr: Search Engine Land
LinkedIn: Search Engine Land Group
Twitter: Search Engine Land Feed

Bragroll