« Search Illustrated: SEM Strategy Matrix | Main | Report: Digg Wants To Sell For $300 Million (Or More) »
Dec. 18, 2007 at 7:48am Eastern by Danny Sullivan
Who's Ranking For Knol? Hello, Wikipedia!
Ah, sweet irony. Yesterday I spent some time raising concerns about knowledge aggregation sites like Wikipedia and the forthcoming Google Knol potentially ranking tops for every search conducted. Today, what's in the top results for Knol? Yep -- a new Wikipedia page on the topic!
The page was created yesterday and took less than 24 hours to show up. Looking at the top results for Knol is also fascinating in how until last week, the Google project wasn't announced, so the results had no reflection of it. Today, they dominate the page:
Let's run down the list.
- KNOL is also the ticker symbol for
Knology, and the Yahoo Finance
page about that company has managed to hang on to the top spot.
- The official Google Blog
post on Knol comes next.
- The official Google
screenshot of an
example Knol page shows up third. Some SEO advice to Google: Get a title tag
on that page so it doesn't look all weird when listed. You might also want to put a
link at the top of the page over to your blog post so people hitting the
screenshot have somewhere to go for more information.
- Search authority Tim Bray warms my heart
by covering
how "transparent" Wikipedia actually is pretty closed given "a forest of
acronym" and other issues that make me nod my head in violent agreement. But
he doesn't see Knol as a solution.
- MarketWatch's page
about Knology comes next.
- Mashable's
write-up
on Knol is fifth. Sniff. We were one of the few places pre-briefed by Google on
Knol and had an article with details not in the official blog post, which is
what the Mashable article and virtually all other news stories were based on.
But we get relegated to position 20 in the search results. Sniff. But congrats
to Mashable, and we'll look forward to when Search Engine Land is a bit older.
With age comes
authority and an easier way to make it to the top. We only
just turned one!
- Wikipedia makes it at
sixth. It'll be interesting to see if the page rises over time. FYI, Squidoo
has three pages about Knol now. I like
this one that's just a copy of the official Google Blog post. I guess the
author missed the Google copyright statement at the bottom of the post. The
other two (here and
here) are pretty basic.
Mahalo's got a nice page of mainly
news commentary (though our write-up, sniff, isn't listed). As for Yahoo
Answers, three questions: how can someone get a Knol invite (here,
and you can't); are there reasons for Yahoo Answers folks to be afraid of Knol
(here),
and how does Knol compare to Wikipedia (here).
- Noah Brier's
two paragraph summary of Knol pulls off a nice coup by getting into the
top ten.
- News.com's write-up on Knol.
- Wired's write-up on Knol.
Also, I took a quick spin at Yahoo, Microsoft, and Ask. Main differences?
- Yahoo results are pretty similar to Google, though the Dutch
Knol-Online makes it in the top
results.
- Microsoft gets Knol Computers,
Knol Farms, and Wikipedia's
Knol Tate page into the
top results. Let's hear it for diversity in search listings! You also get
finance pages about Knology. As for Google Knol, you get one single page of
ZDNet coverage -- not even the official Google Blog post. Come on, Microsoft
-- that post should be there.
- Ask has even more diversity, from Ryan Knol Designs to this page that mentions someone named Knol, among many other people. Google Knol is covered by only a single News.com article about the service. The official blog post doesn't show, and that's just as disappointing as with Microsoft.
|
Like The Story? Vote For It On Yahoo Buzz!
Send me the monthly search newsletter too! (Learn more about our newsletters and feeds) |
Subscribe To Our Search Feed!         
|
| Share & Bookmark This Story! |
By Danny Sullivan
Permalink
Jump To Comments
See Related Stories In: Google: Knol, Search Engines: Mahalo, Search Engines: Wikipedia
