The opinions were flying last week on our sister site, Sphinn, mostly in two discussions about a couple hot topics across the SEO/SEM industry: black hat vs. white hat labels and industry standards/certification.
Sphinn member David Zimmerman kicked it off by starting a discussion about getting rid of the terms “black hat” and “white hat” to describe industry tactics. That conversation led into our “Discussion of the Week,” which asked Is It Time for SEM Industry Standards/Certification? That conversation currently has more than two dozen comments and, since it’s such a hot topic, here are two comments — one from each side of the discussion, pro and con.
On the “con” side, here’s part of what Sphinn member Ian Hough (of TheNamelessThing.com) said:
I think SEO is such a grey area, like the Web in general, that knowing where to draw the lines would be a major problem. The Web is like the wild west, and I think I like it that way. In time it will become more organised and civilised, but it has to be allowed to develop naturally.
On the “pro” side, here’s some of what Sphinn member Michael Martinez (of SEO Theory) had to say:
There is no reason to fear standards. They take nothing away from anyone practicing SEO — but they do give us all something we need: credibility. As an industry, search engine optimization — search engine marketing — has little to no credibility. Standards would vastly improve that situation.
Feel free to add your two cents to that debate now, or read along for more of the most popular stories last week on Sphinn.
Most Comments
- Discussion: Is It Time for SEM Industry Standards/Certification? – As an offshoot to the ongoing discussion about the terms "black hat" and "white hat" tactics, some people have brought up the topic of industry standards and certification. In our "Discussion of the Week," let's hear your thoughts more specifically on that aspect of the debate. Search engine marketing has been around for more than 15 years now. Is it time for a set of industry standards and/or certification the way many other industries do? The floor is open.
- Discussion: White Hat? Black Hat? Who cares! – I am tired of the labels- black hat and white hat. Sure there are good and bad ways to do SEO but these labels have been rendered useless as pejoratives. Rather than speak in terms of the color of an SEO's headgear, we should instead talk about "risk" – how much risk they are willing to take. But it's not really about how risky an SEO is- what is more important is the riskiness of their specific techniques. What do you think? will you join me in dropping the headgear pejoratives and start describing specific techniques as risky or not?
- Whitehat SEO Is a Joke – Are whitehat SEO's nothing more than snake-oil salesmen? Is practicing whitehat SEO little more than wishful thinking? Kris Roadruck from Click2Rank thinks so and outlines why practicing whitehat tactics hardly ever gets anyone to the front page of the SERPS.
Most Tweeted (not already listed above)
- How Google Instant’s Autocomplete Suggestions Work – Comprehensive information from Danny Sullivan at Search Engine Land: "It’s a well known feature of Google. Start typing in a search, and Google offers suggestions before you’ve even finished typing. But how does Google come up with those suggestions? When does Google remove some suggestions? When does Google decide not to interfere? Come along for some answers."
- Why Attention is the New Currency Online – You need to deliver high value content regularly instead of just sharing the same content as someone else. So how do you differentiate yourself in a space full of re-hashed content? First you need to understand and optimize your content for online browsing and reading.
- Is Facebook A Fad? What social networks will look like in five years. – From Farhad Manjoo at Slate: "The big question for the future of social networking isn't whether Facebook will be the largest and most influential site five years from now. It's whether it will be the only one. Will Facebook be the exclusive catalog of our interests and relationships, or will it coexist with several others?"
- Steal These 5 High-Converting Website Tricks – Nice post with real web ecommerce conversion and usability examples.
- How Did You Get Started in SEO? – Chris Winfield of Blue Glass interviews several SEOs from all aspects (in house, international etc.) and asks the question… "How did you get started in SEO?"
Hot On Sphinn: April 4 to April 10, 2011
- Steal These 5 High-Converting Website Tricks – Nice post with real web ecommerce conversion and usability examples.
- If Users Treat Local Search Results Differently, Why Wont Google? – An Enterprise-level Corporate SEO dissects the failings of Google Maps and offers suggestions on improvement.
- WordPress Plugins Security Flaw – A Blackhats Dream – WordPress is a used every day in this industry. This information is important to review if you are suggesting WP or building WP sites for clients. "…then I thought of scaling it. The result? Well using a simple flaw in WordPress Plugins, and some clever strategy, I could sit back and game 100,000’s of relevant links to my sites, and control them all from one place."
- Concerns About adCenter’s Editorial Review Process Are Legitimate – We understand that editorial review exists to ensure users receive high quality and relevant ads, however, the adCenter implementation is an overly cumbersome hurdle in the keyword/ad creation and modification process.
- Please Exit The Link Building – An excerpt: "Bad “link builders”, managed and supported by the terrible SEO Managers that love them – go to Google and mindlessly search. “KEYWORD links”. “KEYWORD resources”. Find a contact e-mail. Change keywords, find another e-mail. Random input in the Google toolbar. Check a PageRank or two. Brag about how high the PageRank of their link was. Repeat, repeat, repeat."
- Indexing the Real World: The Enormous Potential of Hyperlocal Data – As we build layers of information on top of location-based data, we're seeing an increased importance in helping people connect offline after first connecting online. As the author says "Foursquare is the tip of the iceberg."
- Newspapers and Social Media: Still Not Really Getting It – Another good read by Matthew Ingram on how newspapers in particular seem to have a difficult time with journalists interacting on blogs and social sites like Facebook and Twitter. They get publishing and curation, but they still just don't get social.
- How To Use Events as Goals in Google Analytics (V5) – Nice guide to enhanced goal and conversion tracking for the new GA. – Google Analytics (Version 5 Only) now allows you to use events as goals. Events as a goal type…why does this matter? Well, because you can now track more types of site interactions as goals.
- Proven Tips for Reducing Your Abandoned Carts – Before you begin an abandoned cart program, you need to know where your abandons are happening. On the view cart page? In the checkout? On the product page?
- What Does Local Product Availability on Google Place Pages Look Like – Yesterday, Google announced that merchants could now include local products directly on their Places Page. This is part of a long term trend to provide significantly more granular and time based information about local businesses on-line. This has long been part of Google’s local vision that has finally materialized in a way that local merchants can now take advantage of.
- How to Pick a SEM/SEO company using Linkedin & Twitter – Wil Reynolds shows us how a search marketing company can be evaluated by close study of their social media accounts.
- Foursquare introduces directory of pages to help users find brands to follow – Right after Twitter announced a searchable directory, Foursquare was quick to follow.
- Enterprise Social Media Blogging Strategy – A Corporate Blog that isn’t Corporate – Really excellent advice on how to make a corporate blog engaging and desirable to read.
- The Difference Between Web Reporting And Web Analysis – "I know it when I see it" says Avinash Kaushik, and of course he has more on the topic: "If you see a data puke then you know you are looking at the result of web reporting, even if it is called a dashboard. If you see words in English outlining actions that need to be taken, and below the fold you see relevant supporting data, then you are looking at the result of web data analysis."
- Technical SEO: Tools and Approach – Adam Audette explains which technical SEO factors matter for rankings. Guess why some of the best SEOs in the world are highly technical people…
- SEO for online journalists – Article from Mark Nuney of Wordtracker. A how to of SEO for journalists.Great to have your news writers clued up about SEO
- Erasing Individual’s Digital Past – This article explores the challenges in reputation management and the firms that have started as a result.
- 4 Content Strategies for B2B Corporate Blogging – Derek Edmond of Search Engine Watch lays out some good advice and examples for B2B blogging. Content is king as they say, but easier said than done from a B2B perspective.
- Tweet late, email early, and don’t forget about Saturday – Not only does Zarrella recommend tweeting more — he recommends tweeting the same links two or three times a day
This is the latest in a weekly look at the stories that were “hot” on Sphinn in the past week. We’ll post these recaps every week.
Related Topics: Channel: Other | Features: General | Sphinn
Like This Story? Please Share!
Like Our Site? Follow Us!
Follow @sengineland