Local Search: More Is Not Always Better

Recently, we’ve seen a deluge of forecasts about massive financial opportunities associated with the growth of local search and local advertising. Whether you’re a company in the Internet search space, a yellow-pages directory, or a niche player, it is indeed tempting to get overly focused on how to earn your piece of the local search pie.

None of the forecasts mean anything, though if we as an industry don’t first take care of the local consumer. As basic as it may sound, the caveat that you cannot serve advertisers well without first serving your consumers holds especially true in local search.

Providing useful, current, relevant and well-organized content and data is not a luxury, but a necessity. Both consumers and advertisers will always value these traits when considering local online destinations.

In the coming weeks, some colleagues and I will be writing about what we believe are the important issues in local search, covering matters that impact consumers and, ultimately, advertisers.

For starters, let’s look at the notion that “more is better,” especially when it comes to sheer volume of local content.

Consider user-generated content as just one example. While the idea of enriching sites with community is certainly not new, there has been an intensifying buzz about the existing and potential applications of user-generated content to local search, whether we are talking about restaurant, hotel, and entertainment reviews or a local perspective on who the best dentist in Seattle might be.

In and of itself, user-generated content is not the silver-bullet many have made it out to be. While it is absolutely a very efficient way to generate content about local businesses and services, there are pitfalls that may be overlooked in the clamor to see who has the most.

First, sheer volume can overwhelm a consumer. For a popular local business, you can sometimes find many dozens of user-generated reviews and ratings. But at the end of the day, users simply want to make informed decisions. Few of us have the time or inclination to sift through tons of reviews.

Second, keeping current is critical. We often find dated user reviews in the marketplace that have been publicly, and at times prominently, available for years. There is also plenty of turnover in businesses, making it important that any content, whether traditional or user-generated, be reflective of reality in the marketplace.

Finally, staying focused and relevant is key. Reviews should be about the businesses more than the reviewer. If the topic at hand is a restaurant, it’s not uncommon to find a user saying they hate fish, instead of reviewing the quality of the meal at the restaurant. And reviews can veer further off-course, going from talking about a celebrity sighting at or near a restaurant to a discussion about that celebrity’s best or worst movies. User generated content? Yes. Truly relevant to the local searcher? Probably not.

The goal is not content for the sake of content. The goal is content that helps consumers make better decisions. Keeping content useful, current, and relevant creates value for the consumer. There have been noteworthy approaches, such as aggregating content from trusted sources, which gives the consumer a unified, holistic view, and gives content providers valuable distribution. And there have been interesting advances in managing the volume of content, such as review-summary features on sites like Hotels.com and the Open View technology we recently unveiled on Open List. In both, technology intelligently analyzes the breadth of content and provides a concise paragraph integrating key items from user and editorial reviews. There remains a lot more work to do in this area, especially as additional content types such as video join the mix. The progress will be interesting to track.

In the months to follow, we will expand on other topics relevant to the local search marketplace, such as how better decision tools (and a better experience) for consumers yield richer and more targeted opportunities for advertisers. The trick is getting consumers to come back to your site because they want to, not just because they need to.

Chris Linnett is director of Open List for Marchex. The Locals Only column appears on Mondays at Search Engine Land.

Opinions expressed in the article are those of the guest author and not necessarily Search Engine Land.

Related Topics: Channel: Local | Local Search Column | Search Engines: Maps & Local Search Engines | Search Engines: Travel Search Engines


About The Author: is director of Open List for Marchex, where he blogs regularly about all things local at LocalPoint, in addition to his regular column for Search Engine Land. The Locals Only column appears on Mondays at Search Engine Land.

Connect with the author via: Email


Get all the top search stories emailed daily!  


Other ways to share:

Read before commenting! We welcome constructive comments and allow any that meet our common sense criteria. This means being respectful and polite to others. It means providing helpful information that contributes to a story or discussion. It means leaving links only that substantially add further to a discussion. Comments using foul language, being disrespectful to others or otherwise violating what we believe are common sense standards of discussion will be deleted. Comments may also be removed if they are posted from anonymous accounts. You can read more about our comments policy here.
  • http://glinden.blogspot.com Greg Linden

    “Providing useful, current, relevant and well-organized content and data is … a necessity …. Users simply want to make informed decisions …. The goal is content that helps consumers make better decisions.”

    This is why I think newspapers are in a better position to do local search than anyone else. Newspapers should own local.

    Newspapers have remarkable content on businesses and events in their communities. They should make themselves the authoritative source for local. They should be the experts on their communities and reap the traffic from searchers seeking that expertise.

  • http://WhatWhyWhere.net Guido

    A website is only as good as the information it provides. And as the title states – more content is certainly not always better. Large websites that blindly flood their pages with ad-funded information are by now hardly valuable considering today’s over-saturation of online resources. Whether it be information on restaurants, area entertainment, or where to find the best mechanic, providing up-to-date, objective information in an organized manner is crucial for online data. New sites like WhatWhyWhere.net are ideal for local consumers as well as travelers looking for a functioning and efficient online marketplace. The website serves as somewhat of a
    search-filter, highlighting which companies are currently “best” in their field of service. The website’s information source (an actual human) has nothing to gain by his/her review or contribution, short of boosting the integrity of WhatWhyWhere.net as the ultimate online resource for consumers – not in terms of quantity, at all, but quality. We’re starting off in Havertown, PA this week, and circling out. Let me know what you think of the design or the premise.

  • http://www.seobrien.com seobrien

    As a local search user, I want to one engine that can give me everything going on or available in my vicinity. Local search is the most atrocious experience online because I have to go to 10 different sources before I feel like I’m aware of everything.
    The challenge lies in personalized, targeted results customized only to the person searching. What of companies like Zvents (http://www.zvents.com) which have recognized that more is better when it comes to comprehensiveness yet personalization is key?

  • http://www.boorah.com Eric

    I heartily agree that ‘more is not necessarily better’ for local reviews — BooRah is another company that’s pioneered in using technology to simplify the user experience… with automated summary generation like you mention, but also automated rating generation: For restaurants, for example – Food, Service, and Ambiance scores are automatically generated by algorithms that analyze the actual text of what people have written, to make it easier for consumers to find a good place to eat. Glad to hear you’re going to cover the user experience more on this site.

  • http://www.looklocally.com Judy Luchtman

    Chris points out that all the opportunity in search won’t matter if we don’t take care of the local consumer. The book, the Long Tail of Search helps explain what that means. In searching, when a consumer looks for something, typically they start with a search engine and research using very general search words such as “Granite Countertop”. As they get closer to the buying decision the searcher becomes much more specific, i.e.: “Granite Countertop Denton” and in most cases when services or products are delivered locally, they include the location.

    That said, content that is optimized for the local market should include accurate, relevant information including the location information. LookLocally.com, a hybrid solution combining a business directory with local search marketing, provides deep, relevant content via custom landing pages for local advertisers. Search Engines are struggling to keep up with the billions of pages out there. Websites that deliver accurate & relevant results have become far more important to Search Engines seeking to improve local search.


Get Our News, Everywhere!

Daily Email:

Follow Search Engine Land on Twitter @sengineland Like Search Engine Land on Facebook Follow Search Engine Land on Google+ Get the Search Engine Land Feed Connect with Search Engine Land on LinkedIn Check out our Tumblr! See us on Pinterest


Click to watch SMX conference video

Join us at one of our SMX or MarTech events:

United States


Australia & China

Learn more about: SMX | MarTech

Free Daily Search News Recap!

SearchCap is a once-per-day newsletter update - sign up below and get the news delivered to you!



Search Engine Land Periodic Table of SEO Success Factors

Get Your Copy
Read The Full SEO Guide