Will “Google Me” Be A Worthy Facebook Challenger Or Will It Be DOA?

Let’s take “Google Me” seriously as a social networking site, successor to Orkut and overall Facebook challenger. As everyone by now knows Digg’s Kevin Rose started a wave of coverage when he asserted over the weekend, in a Twitter post now removed, that Google was working on a Facebook competitor.

Yesterday I asked Google for a comment and received a friendly but anonymous response: “We do not comment on rumor or speculation.” Of course not. That almost certainly means that something is coming.

I told several people yesterday that it was probably a beefed up version of Google Profiles. And that’s almost certainly part of whatever will show up.

Last night there was more “information” from Adam D’Angelo, former Facebook CTO and co-founder of Q&A service Quora. On Quora he says:
Here is what I’ve pieced together from some reliable sources:

  • This is not a rumor. This is a real project. There are a large number of people working on it. I am completely confident about this.
  • They realized that Buzz wasn’t enough and that they need to build out a full, first-class social network. They are modeling it off of Facebook.
  • Unlike previous attempts (before Buzz at least), this is a high-priority project within Google.
  • They had assumed that Facebook’s growth would slow as it grew, and that Facebook wouldn’t be able to have too much leverage over them, but then it just didn’t stop, and now they are really scared.

(Incidentally this turns into really shrewd “side PR” for Quora, where there’s lots of activity and discussion around this topic.)

Facebook could eventually overtake Google as the most visited site on the internet. That would be a mostly symbolic event when/if it happens but it would freak Google out and would suggest to the media that Google is in decline. Hence the comment above . . . “and now they are really scared.”

Currently Facebook is not a “threat” to Google as a search engine. Only with a radical overhaul could search on Facebook start to peel away usage from Google. I’m not saying that’s not hypothetically possible. But it doesn’t really look probable for the foreseeable future at least.

Back to “Google Me.” What would need to show up to make a viable Facebook competitor? That’s a very challenging thing to imagine. Here are some general thoughts:

  • First and foremost Google would need to get privacy right; it would need to be the anti-Facebook, bending over backwards to protect user privacy
  • It would need to focus not on rapid, viral growth or Google’s “needs” but on users and their interests and needs
  • It would need to be a place where private networks of people could exist and communicate and where people could create multiple profiles/identities that correspond to their real-world lives (work, school, family, etc.)
  • It would need to enable people to share and upload media easily, tapping into Picasa and YouTube
  • It could be a communications platform and integrate Google Talk and/or Google Voice
  • It could use the Aardvark infrastructure to enable people to ask their networks questions and get recommendations
  • It could use Latitude and Buzz for location-based tips and information on the go
  • It would need to be mobile and offer an app
  • It could include Calendar and/or a simplified version of Wave for collaboration and planning
  • It could put Google search at the core to enable information to be quickly obtained and shared
  • It might be an apps platform too

Many of these capabilities and tools do exist on Facebook now. And this laundry list of possibilities does not a product make. That’s the daunting task that Google faces: how to build something that accomplishes multiple goals, does one or two things things that Facebook doesn’t and is put together in an elegant way.

A different sort of user experience and interface could be a way into differentiation for Google Me. But simply “modeling it off of Facebook,” as the D’Angelo post suggests, won’t fly. A copy of Facebook with the Google logo on it is all but destined to fail.

Look at Buzz, a product that perhaps isn’t dead technically but may effectively be so. Beyond the privacy fiasco and the botched launch, Buzz never fully answered the question “why?” Why should I use it?  Similarly, for Google Me, what capabilities or services or tasks does it offer or enable that Facebook doesn’t or can’t? Because if Google Me can’t answer the “why question” it’s DOA.

Google Buzz became “yet another” site and tool to update. A Google social network and successor to Orkut fundamentally must answer this “why question” in view of Facebook’s near total market dominance.

It’s the flip side of the question that all other search engines must answer vis-a-vis Google.

Postscript: One interesting additional thing to consider is whether Google might try to lead with mobile and make any site/network primarily mobile but with an online component. Google is placing more and more emphasis on mobility, even to the point of slogan-izing it: “mobile first.”

Related Topics: Channel: Social | Facebook | Google: Accounts & Profiles | Google: General | Google: Mobile | Google: Orkut | Google: Q & A | Google: Web Search


About The Author: is a Contributing Editor at Search Engine Land. He writes a personal blog Screenwerk, about SoLoMo issues and connecting the dots between online and offline. He also posts at Internet2Go, which is focused on the mobile Internet. Follow him @gsterling.

Connect with the author via: Email | Twitter | Google+ | LinkedIn


Get all the top search stories emailed daily!  


Other ways to share:

Read before commenting! We welcome constructive comments and allow any that meet our common sense criteria. This means being respectful and polite to others. It means providing helpful information that contributes to a story or discussion. It means leaving links only that substantially add further to a discussion. Comments using foul language, being disrespectful to others or otherwise violating what we believe are common sense standards of discussion will be deleted. Comments may also be removed if they are posted from anonymous accounts. You can read more about our comments policy here.
  • http://www.returnondigital.com/dave-ashworth.php Dave Ashworth

    Let’s face it, this will probably go the same way as Google Wave and Buzz.

    Facebook is far to ingrained into everyday life that I doubt very much we will see any social networking site challenge it for some time, if ever.

    Google need to be more innovatitve and come up with a service that can take social media in a new direction, rather than trying to compete with what is already there, well established and the leader in it’s SM niche.

  • http://www.actwebconsulting.com ACTeeple

    “Because if Google Me can’t answer the “why question” it’s DOA.”

    This is so true. Last night, I was watching TV and one of the characters said as he was saying goodbye, “I’m on Facebook.” This just shows how integrated Facebook has become in our culture. No need to bother writing down contact info – you can find me on Facebook.

    Google Me (or whatever it ends up being called) needs to not only differentiate itself from Facebook, but has to offer something that will appeal to those many frustrated, yet loyal FB users.

  • brallsplp

    I am hoping for DOA as I am getting very bored of Google EVERYTHING!

  • http://www.intotemptation.net JustJss

    FaceBook is probably too big to fail quickly.

    So was AOL.

    If “Google Me” can allow me to present myself to friends, acquaintances and the world more the way I wish to present myself than does FaceBook, I would make Google Me my primary social networking platform.

    Facebook has allowed me to find old friends (for me, it made “Classmates” obsolete) and also to connect with a few new ones. But it has mostly served its purpose already.

    Knowing which of my friends are prone to playing Farmville is useful information, too … Thanks, FaceBook, for providing Zynga-type games as a measure of social IQ. What a plague those things are …

  • jlong7

    I want multiple profiles. Google would know so much more about me than Facebook does if I could show a different profile to different social sets without the friend knowing to which social set they belonged or even that there were other profiles. And I’d like for these profiles to be layerable (wife can be part of “family” and “friends” but not “fight night buddies,” and Joe can be part of “fight night buddies” and “friends,” but not “family”). In real life, I can have members of different social sets mix at a party. But my church friends know not to discuss my religious views with friends that may belong to different political parties. In fact, for me, this hide and seek is not hiding something I’m doing wrong, it’s intellectual flirtation, the gradual disrobing of my identity to others who share similar interests to mine. We find that our closest friends are those that we can share ourselves completely. I’m certainly not going to be running around naked at work. This idea that privacy is dead is simply turning everyones life into a PR/Advertising laced bland bullshit. Make me feel safe and Google will be my one true friend who knows all of my deepest darkest secrets:-) Google will know my religion, political views, favorite sports. My wife is scandalized every time I let it slip to one of her friends that I like barbaric sports like MMA. Google will even know whether I prefer the blond or brunette score card girls. I know, that’s what Zuckerberg was referring to when he said, “If you aren’t doing anything wrong, you don’t have anything to hide.” But who’s perfect?

Get Our News, Everywhere!

Daily Email:

Follow Search Engine Land on Twitter @sengineland Like Search Engine Land on Facebook Follow Search Engine Land on Google+ Get the Search Engine Land Feed Connect with Search Engine Land on LinkedIn Check out our Tumblr! See us on Pinterest


Click to watch SMX conference video

Join us at one of our SMX or MarTech events:

United States


Australia & China

Learn more about: SMX | MarTech

Free Daily Search News Recap!

SearchCap is a once-per-day newsletter update - sign up below and get the news delivered to you!



Search Engine Land Periodic Table of SEO Success Factors

Get Your Copy
Read The Full SEO Guide