Note: By submitting this form, you agree to Third Door Media's terms. We respect your privacy.

What the heck is going on with Google Keyword Planner?

Technical glitches and close variants (sometimes) come to Keyword Planner

Ginny Marvin on June 30, 2016 at 12:46 pm

First there were the error notices that users have to have an active campaign, not just an AdWords account to access Keyword Planner. Then came combined search volumes for close variants.

A Google spokesperson has confirmed with Search Engine Land that users do not have to have an active campaign to use Keyword Planner. On social media, Google told users that the error was the result of a technical issue that was being fixed. When Keyword Planner launched inside AdWords in 2013, replacing the open Keyword Tool, it got a cool reception. So there was alarm when some users got the error message telling them they’d also have to have an active AdWords campaign to use it. The error didn’t affect all accounts; still it got people speculating whether it just a glitch or Google backtracking. Either way, for now at least we can move on.

So, to close variants and the resulting combined search volume results. Google isn’t commenting the move; we asked. Close variants grouping is not necessarily unexpected — Google replaced exact match targeting with close variants in ad campaigns in 2014 — and yet it is often inconsistent. Sometimes plurals are grouped, sometimes they aren’t. Sometimes acronyms and abbreviations are grouped with their full phrase, sometimes not. Sometimes search volumes for synonyms are combined, other times not. Sometimes combined words and misspellings are grouped, other time they are not. And apparently we search for dogs and cats at the same rate.

Here are just some examples of oddities I’ve found:

Scenario	Search term	Avg. monthly searches
Plural treated the same.	cat	3,350,000
	cats	3,350,000
–	–	–
Plural treated differently	seo service	6,600
	seo services	27,100
–	–	–
Same volume for abbreviation	pay per click	135,000
	ppc	135,000
–	–	–
Then different volumes for abbreviation and synonym	search engine marketing	12,100
	search marketing	2,900
	sem	368,000
–	–	–
Some combined words get different volumes, some don’t	car wash	550,000
	carwash	550,000
	dog walker	22,200
	dogwalker	2,900
	auto body shop	49,500
	autobody shop	2,400
–	–	–
Plural and abbreviations reported separately	cfp	110,000
	cfps	4,400
	certified financial planners	480
–	–	–
Spelling choice reported separately	financial advisor	74,000
	financial adviser	6,600
–	–	–
Not measured as synonyms	ecommerce business	8,100
	ecommerce company	4,400
	ecommerce firm	110

Synonyms and word order measured separately	remarketing	22,200
	retargeting	18,100
	remarketing adwords	2,400
	adwords remarketing	1,600

What does this mean for search marketers?

First, it’s a good reminder that the search volumes (and estimated CPCs) in Keyword Planner should be seen as directional signals, not hard facts. Second, if you’ve been benchmarking certain keywords and/or keyword groups over time, you’ll may or may not see shifts in historical reporting. Third, sometimes you’ll get granularity, sometimes you won’t. Which brings us right back to point number one: yes, it’s kind of annoying some keyword variations are grouped and some aren’t, but it might offer some directional insight into when granular targeting could make more of an impact in your efforts.

About The Author

Ginny Marvin

Ginny Marvin is Third Door Media's Editor-in-Chief, managing day-to-day editorial operations across all of our publications. Ginny writes about paid online marketing topics including paid search, paid social, display and retargeting for Search Engine Land, Marketing Land and MarTech Today. With more than 15 years of marketing experience, she has held both in-house and agency management positions. She can be found on Twitter as @ginnymarvin.