Some Google Maps Indexing Confusion

Locally Type found a mistake in a Google search result, showing a Yahoo Maps URL but with a plus box that reveals a Google Map. Here’s the result that lead to the post: Needham, MA 02494. The actual Yahoo Map is a link down on the page. Google’s Matt Cutts responded to the post in […]

Chat with SearchBot

Locally Type found a mistake in a Google search result, showing a Yahoo Maps URL but with a plus box that reveals a Google Map. Here’s the result that lead to the post: Needham, MA 02494. The actual Yahoo Map is a link down on the page.


Google’s Matt Cutts responded to the post in comments:

Huh. Looks like we indexed a Yahoo search results page for maps. I’m surprised Yahoo doesn’t exclude that url in robots.txt, but I’ll pass on the report. Thanks!

Google previously put links to Yahoo and MapQuest (as well as its own maps) at the top of pages that generated maps, but in January of this year stopped that practice, saying that the new Google Maps OneBox (now replaced by Universal Search) offered a better overall experience.

Just for fun, I plugged the “Needham, MA 02494” query into the other major engines to see what would happen:

AOL (the problem isn’t reproduced, despite using the same Google search results):

ScreenHunter_779.jpg

Ask:

ScreenHunter_780.jpg

Microsoft/Windows Live

ScreenHunter_781.jpg

Yahoo (nice Shortcut here)

ScreenHunter_775.jpg


Opinions expressed in this article are those of the guest author and not necessarily Search Engine Land. Staff authors are listed here.


About the author

Greg Sterling
Contributor
Greg Sterling is a Contributing Editor to Search Engine Land, a member of the programming team for SMX events and the VP, Market Insights at Uberall.

Get the must-read newsletter for search marketers.