This July: Try Google-Free Fridays!
Back in 2002, I called Google the "Marcia Brady" of search. Fans of the Brady Bunch know that Marcia was one of six children, and middle daughter Jan felt Marcia got all the attention. "Marcia, Marcia, Marcia," she’d often complain, just as today, it often seems to be "Google, Google, Google" that’s all you hear […]
Back in 2002, I
Google the "Marcia Brady" of search. Fans of the Brady Bunch know that Marcia
was one of six children, and middle daughter Jan felt Marcia got all the
attention. "Marcia, Marcia, Marcia," she’d often complain, just as today, it
often seems to be "Google, Google, Google" that’s all you hear about in search.
There’s more to search than Google, of course. To encourage people to
understand this, I’m resurrecting an idea from 2003: Google-Free Friday. In
July, each Friday, we’re encouraging everyone to try a search engine other than
Understand that this is most definitely NOT motivated because Google is
somehow now too big, too scary or bad in anyway. Sure, plenty of that sentiment
is going around right now. John Battelle
blogged today about
perhaps hitting a "Google saturation point" and not wanting too much of his life
going through one source. Last week, Google
took fire for
privacy issues. Everyone
Fears Google (Again) & Will The Last Googler To Leave Turn The Lights Out?
covers more fear of Google that seemed to hit a new height in May (and
14 "Is Google Evil?"
Tipping Points Since 2001 covers other fear benchmarks over time).
Instead, I was inspired by the
Without Google effort that Alt Search Engines tried earlier this month. I
felt that fizzled for a few reasons:
- It seemed to be suggested without little advance notice for people to
- Rather than be a day without Google, it was really a day without using any
of the major search engines — which was going to inevitably be an impossible
option for many people. As David Berkowitz
remarked, "The top 5 are the top 5 for a reason," with the two chief
reasons being that they offer comprehensive web listings with high relevancy.
So let’s try it again, with a new twist. In July, on each Friday, use a
different major search engine that is not Google. Here’s the schedule, with a
different service to be used, in alphabetical order:
While I’m calling this Google-Free Friday, it doesn’t mean you have to be
entirely Google Free. It’s mainly applicable to searching. On these Fridays,
feel free to use Gmail, Google Analytics, AdWords, Google Docs or whatever
Google products you might normally use that aren’t specifically search related.
However, when it comes to seeking information from the web, on each day, use
these alternatives. This also includes not just general web search but also
vertical/specialized searching. Try Yahoo Maps on July 27, rather than Google
Maps. Use Windows Live Image search on July 20, rather than Google Images.
To help you, on each day for a specific search engine, we’ll post a solid
list of various search offerings available from that service. You’ll likely be
surprised to see how much they offer. On the following Monday, we’ll also
provide a place for people to share reactions and remarks.
I started out saying this isn’t designed to be anti-Google. It really isn’t.
To echo what Richard MacManus
Note that our intent wasn’t to "boycott" Google – Google is number 1 for a
reason, which is that it’s the best search engine around. The reason behind the
‘Day Without Google’ was purely to encourage people to experiment with and test
out some of the hundreds of Google competitors; maybe even catch a glimpse of
the future dominant search engine.
Agreed. This isn’t a boycott Google exercise. It’s an attempt to help people
open their eyes to alternatives. In fact, the days might even help Google
itself. Ever tried a particular product, such as a toothpaste, then wonder if
you perhaps should be using something else? This often happens to me. Then I try
the alternative and decide I’m happy with my original choice.
If you’re the biggest Google fan, using an alternative might help reassure
you that you’ve got ever reason to continue loving Google. If you’re nervous
about Google, trying an alternative might help you discover that if they are a
dominant search player, this might be down to having earned that dominance
through satisfaction. And, of course, you might discover that there’s something
else out there you like better — a particular feature, a particular vertical
search or perhaps an entire new service. Time to check things out!
Finally, I said earlier that I was resurrecting this idea. I was thinking
about the name "Google-Free Friday" yesterday, then decided to check today and
make sure it was original. It wasn’t. Back in 2003, Pete Prodoehl of RasterWeb
wrote a short
Google-Free Friday post, saying:
I was considering trying an experiment. Switching search engines for a day.
I mean, we used to have Microsoft-Free Fridays, right? What about a
Google-Free Friday? Will you still find what you’re looking for? Let’s find
Is AlltheWeb the successor to Google? I dunno, but there’s some interesting
stuff in FAST News…
Oh, if you don’t want to use AlltheWeb, there’s always Teoma, or Yahoo!
or… Hmmm, I suppose you could search Google for other search engines – wait,
don’t do that…
I’m sure I must have seen mention of Pete’s post those years ago (probably
via Dave Winer, who
Microsoft-Free Fridays in 2001), so the name and idea must have percolated
back up in my mind. It was fun to think about then, and it remains as relevant
if not more so today.