AdWords ad rotation settings to get trimmed: Optimize or don’t

The signs were all pointing this way.

Google announced Tuesday a change to the ad rotation settings in AdWords. There will soon be just two options: “Optimize: Prefer best performing ads” and the not-so-subtly named “Do not optimize: Rotate ads indefinitely.”

The options currently appear as:

A bit of backstory

Five years ago is ancient history in digital marketing, but anyone who worked in paid search in 2012 will remember the backlash that came when Google announced the “rotate evenly” setting would last just 30 days before reverting to “optimize for clicks.” That was in April. In October of that year, Google reinstated “rotate indefinitely.” Since then, advertisers have been able to set their ad tests to “rotate indefinitely,” “rotate evenly” for at least 90 days, or rely on Google’s machine learning to optimize for clicks or conversions.

Google has made it clear for some time that it would really prefer that advertisers select the “optimize ad rotation” settings. Googler Matt Lawson laid out the case against “rotate indefinitely” in a 2015 column. Over the past year, with the removal of ads from the right rail and the introduction of expanded text ads, Google has been steadily encouraging advertisers to move beyond A/B tests, run at least three ads per ad group and let the “optimize ad rotation” settings determine which ad to serve. This all fits into the broader picture of machine learning’s increasing pervasiveness and influence on AdWords systems as a whole.

More details on this change

1. Ad rotation can be set at the ad group level instead of only at the campaign level. (That could make management more confusing, but it does offer a dose of more fine-grained control.)
2. The “Do not optimize” option provides the standard even rotation. (Soon enough, we will refer to this setting as “old school.”)
3. The new optimize setting “will optimize your ads for clicks in each individual auction using signals like keyword, search term, device, location and more.”
4. To optimize for conversions, use Smart Bidding (automated bidding strategies). In May, Google added a “Maximize conversions” Smart Bidding strategy. If Smart Bidding strategies are used, ads will automatically be set to Optimize.
5. Yes, Google strongly suggests running at least three ads in an ad group: “The more of your ads our system can choose from, the better the expected ad performance.”
6. The change will take effect in late September.

While there may be some grumbling about this tweak, I expect most marketers won’t be all that surprised or flustered by it. Google can thank Facebook in part for conditioning advertisers to give up ad-serving control to the machines. The next step is to phase out “rotate indefintely” altogether.

Opinions expressed in this article are those of the guest author and not necessarily Search Engine Land. Staff authors are listed here.

About The Author

Ginny Marvin

Ginny Marvin was Third Door Media’s former Editor-in-Chief (October 2018 to December 2020), running the day-to-day editorial operations across all publications and overseeing paid media coverage. Ginny Marvin wrote about paid digital advertising and analytics news and trends for Search Engine Land, Marketing Land and MarTech Today. With more than 15 years of marketing experience, Ginny has held both in-house and agency management positions. She can be found on Twitter as @ginnymarvin.