Sign up for our daily recaps of the ever-changing search marketing landscape.
Natalie Portman Is Not Dead – Despite What Google’s Real Time Results (Sometimes) Say
Irony & deja vu. Earlier this year, a rumor swept the internet that Jeff Goldblum had died — and for a short time, searches on Google seemed to confim it. Now the same is happening to Natalie Portman — who like Goldblum, is alive and well despite what Google’s search results say.
Jeff Goldblum Is NOT Dead (Despite What Google Says) has the background on what happened with Goldblum and how a joke site called FakeAWish allows people make a story about any celebrity being dead in an accident (with one scenario placing this in New Zealand).
With Goldblum, Google News had picked up an actual news article that someone had written based on the rumor, making the rumor seem real:
That’s a disadvantage to not having real time results. If Google had them, then at least people would have seen other people saying the rumor wasn’t true.
Then again, people searching for Natalie Portman right now on Google are seeing things like this:
That’s “Global Associated News” confirming she’s dead, right in the top results at Google.
Now right below it, you see someone saying the rumor is false. In fact, I see plenty of that, such as in this example:
So in some ways, the real time results are compensating for the rumor. Unlike with Goldblum’s case, the real time results are actually helping to cast doubt that this “death” is real.
But it also depends on when you see them. If they aren’t scrolling with new stuff, you might get a “confirmation” without a rumor. And when the rumor first started, you might not have gotten confirmations at all.
I also continued to see glitches with the results similar to what I saw with reports of Brittany Murphy’s sadly real death (see Brittany Murphy’s Death & Google’s Real Time Search Results). Google’s real time results often did not refresh and usually failed to keep pace with new information that was showing in Twitter’s own real time results. And there was repetition, such as this:
There’s “Global Associated News” again. I saw this site pushing its story and succeeding in Google’s real time results three times in about three minutes.
Some opinions expressed in this article may be those of a guest author and not necessarily Search Engine Land. Staff authors are listed here.