Search Engine Land
  • SEO
    • > All SEO
    • > What Is SEO?
    • > SEO Periodic Table
    • > Google: SEO
    • > Bing SEO
    • > Google Algorithm Updates
  • PPC
    • > All PPC
    • > What is PPC?
    • > Google Ads
    • > Microsoft Ads
    • > The Periodic Tables of PPC
  • Focuses
    • > Local
    • > Commerce
    • > Shopify SEO Guide
    • > Content
    • > Email Marketing Periodic Table
    • > Social Media Marketing
    • > Analytics
    • > Search Engine Land Awards
    • > All Focuses
  • SMX
  • Webinars
  • Intelligence Reports
  • White Papers
  • About
    • > About Search Engine Land
    • > Newsletter
    • > Third Door Media
    • > Advertise

Processing...Please wait.

Search Engine Land » Channel » Content » France Gives Google 15 Days To Apply Right-To-Be-Forgotten To Global Results

France Gives Google 15 Days To Apply Right-To-Be-Forgotten To Global Results

EU privacy regulators believe Europe-only application of rule undermines its effectiveness.

Greg Sterling on June 12, 2015 at 11:02 am

erase-chalkboard-school-rtbf-ss-1920

France is putting pressure on Google to apply the Right to Be Forgotten (RTBF) globally “to all domains” by issuing an ultimatum. The Wall Street Journal quotes the head of France’s regulator CNIL saying, “For delisting to be effective, it must be world-wide.” The regulator’s own statement is here.

To date Google has only de-indexed content for European domains, although the company has recently made it somewhat more challenging to get to Google.com from within Europe. Google has taken the position that because RTBF is a European law it should only apply to content shown in Europe and not the entire Google.com index.

For its part, Google gave this statement:

We’ve been working hard to strike the right balance in implementing the European Court’s ruling, co-operating closely with
data protection authorities. The ruling focused on services directed to European users, and that’s the approach we are taking in complying with it.

Google seems to believe censoring only on EU-specific sites is effective because it says less than 5% of searches from the EU happen through Google.com.

The French and many European privacy regulators believe that RTBF is undermined by the retention of content in the Google.com index. Accordingly, CNIL is giving Google 15 days to comply with its demand or face sanctions. The potential fine is €150,000 ($169,000). Google would be permitted to challenge the sanctions, if applied, in court.

RTBF removal data

Google’s is absolutely correct and the European drive for global removal of links overreaches. Neither CNIL nor any European privacy regulator should be permitted to control what content is available outside of their immediate jurisdictions. Indeed, the EU has no legal jurisdiction over Google outside of its territorial domain.

Acceding to the French-EU position on this question would be tantamount to saying that the Chinese government should be allowed to determine how the world views the Tiananmen Square massacre and censor content not just in China but globally.

Conceptually RTBF attempts to balance European citizens’ legitimate privacy interests with the public’s “right to know.” While this is certainly a legitimate and even desirable objective, the application of the rule is legally incoherent. Online publications, which contain the disputed links or content, are not required to change or remove that content. It only applies to search engine results — not the original publishers.

Since the May 2014 European Court of Justice ruling that announced RTBF, Google reports that it has received nearly 270,000 removal requests covering almost a million disputed links. It has granted roughly 41 percent of those requests.

See also our analysis piece, How The Myth Of Google Censorship Was Busted By The EU & Canada.


Opinions expressed in this article are those of the guest author and not necessarily Search Engine Land. Staff authors are listed here.


New on Search Engine Land

    SEO reporting to impress: How to successfully report your SEO process, efforts and result

    9 ways to become an SEO problem-solver

    More FAQ rich results being displayed in Google Search

    Webinar: Benchmark your social media performance for a competitive edge

    Google releases May 2022 broad core update

About The Author

Greg Sterling
Greg Sterling is a Contributing Editor to Search Engine Land, a member of the programming team for SMX events and the VP, Market Insights at Uberall.

Related Topics

ContentGooglePPCSEO

Get the daily newsletter search marketers rely on.

Processing...Please wait.

See terms.

ATTEND OUR EVENTS

The SMX Conference logo.

Learn actionable search marketing tactics that can help you drive more traffic, leads, and revenue.

March 8-9, 2022: Master Classes (virtual)

June 14-15, 2022: SMX Advanced (virtual)

November 15-16, 2022: SMX Next (virtual)

Learn More About Our SMX Events

The MarTech Conference logo.

Discover time-saving technologies and actionable tactics that can help you overcome crucial marketing challenges.

Start Discovering Now: Spring (virtual)

September 28-29, 2022: Fall (virtual)

Learn More About Our MarTech Events

Webinars

Benchmark Your Social Media Performance For a Competitive Edge

Take a Crawl, Walk, Run Approach to Multi-Channel ABM

Content Comes First: Transform Your Operations With DAM

See More Webinars

Intelligence Reports

Enterprise SEO Platforms: A Marketer’s Guide

Enterprise Identity Resolution Platforms

Email Marketing Platforms: A Marketer’s Guide

Enterprise Sales Enablement Platforms: A Marketer’s Guide

Enterprise Digital Experience Platforms: A Marketer’s Guide

Enterprise Call Analytics Platforms: A Marketer’s Guide

See More Intelligence Reports

White Papers

The State of Influencer Pricing

How to Measure Influencer Performance

Reputation Management For Healthcare Organizations

Unlock the App Marketing Potential of QR Codes

Realising the power of virtual events for demand generation

See More Whitepapers

Receive daily search news and analysis.

Processing...Please wait.

Topics

  • SEO
  • PPC

Our Events

  • Search Marketing Expo - SMX
  • MarTech

About

  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Marketing Opportunities
  • Staff

Follow Us

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Newsletters
  • RSS
  • Youtube

© 2022 Third Door Media, Inc. All rights reserved.