Why So Many Blogs Fail (And What to Do About It)

It’s a safe bet that right this minute, someone, somewhere, is advising a small business owner to start a blog. And it’s an equally safe bet that this blog will be a waste of time.

Blogging used to be an effective strategy, but its current popularity is a holdover. And case study after case study obscure the fact that successful blog-driven marketing campaigns are a rarity; unvisited, abandoned company blogs are far more common.

Blogging is not just one of those strategies that needs to be tailored to specific situations: it’s a strategy that, by default, will fail.

The online content business has gotten insanely competitive since blogging started, and only the most aggressive sites succeed. And there’s plenty of over-optimistic competition.

Why Does This Seem Like Good Advice?

Starting a blog was a great way to distinguish your business from a horde of local businesses offering pretty similar services. Even if you weren’t a great writer and didn’t have a ton of insight, merely giving people an inside look at how the business really worked was enough to give you an edge.

That was true from roughly 2003 to, oh say, 2004. But blogs are no longer unique—if you’re writing a blog, you’re competing on writing quality, insight, and marketing chops.

But if you’re writing a blog to promote a small business, you’re probably a dentist, a plumber, an accountant— you’re pitting yourself against professional bloggers, both in the industry and at local news venues.

On top of that, SERPs are less forgiving than they used to be. In the early days, a local florist’s blog with a couple solid links could rank #1 for a term like “[city name] + florist”.

Now, that blog is below three AdWords slots, seven local results, a list of related terms, and a geographic disambiguation page.

For users, that might be positive: an algorithm designed to detect topical authorities is not an algorithm designed to facilitate transactions, but lots of searches are transactional.

Blogging as a marketing tool relies on a sort of viral loop:

  1. You write something interesting about being, say, a podiatrist.
  2. People hear about your podiatry blog, and link to it.
  3. These links make Google treat you as an authority on podiatry; your site copy indicates that you’re in, say, Des Moines, so they rank you for [Podiatry or something similar] + [Des Moines or somewhere nearby].

Now, the viral loop is more like:

  1. You write the 10th most interesting thing about podiatry that day.
  2. *crickets*

Content produced is growing faster than time available to consume it, so the minimum threshold for interesting content keeps going up.

That’s why big media companies keep launching blogs, and why so many rapidly-growing blog networks focus on consumer-facing content like celebrity gossip.

Idea, Execution, Or Both?

The “macro”-situation isn’t the only problem: even small business blogs that do get read tend to miss some big opportunities.

The classic mistakes that small business bloggers make:

Letting category pages get indexed

The default configuration on many blogging software packages allows massive category pages to get indexed. This does generate some traffic, but mostly from extremely long queries that include keywords found in multiple blog posts. These queries are low-quality traffic with a very high bounce rate.

Not treating blog posts as landing pages

Very, very few people will subscribe to a local business’s blog unless they already like the business. To turn new blog visitors into new customers, every blog post should close with a relevant call-to-action.

If you’re writing about this season’s newest floral arrangements, you’d better be selling them by the end of the post. (That’s going to benefit a blog much more than a comments section with zero comments.)

Prioritizing blogs ahead of newsletters

What’s the best outlet for a small business owner’s blogging energies? A newsletter. Newsletters cut through the clutter, and can be crafted to sell to existing customers. Thanks to services like Constant Contact and Mailchimp, they’re about as easy to set up as a typical blog platform.

Newsletters are a great medium for two-sided offers (“Buy one with a friend, and you each get another one free!”) which can have a multiplicative effect on sales. And posting newsletters to your site gets a big chunk of the benefits of blogging, at a much smaller cost. (It’s no accident that the big group-buying companies are a small business plus email play, not a small business plus SEO play.)

Key Takeaways

These are not purely small business problems, but they’re endemic to the field. The main reason for this is budgeting and rounding: at a big company, someone might work 40 hours per week running an in-house blog and doing related activities.

If they’re not pulling their weight, that will be readily apparent. But at a company one tenth the size, an in-house blogger might spend 4 hours per week on the blog. It’s hard to count that as a direct cost, so it’s hard to measure the return on investment.

Blogging certainly isn’t dead. In fact, its liveliness is part of the problem; there are just too many great writers out there, so competing with them is hardly the optimal way to invest time and energy.

Spend that time cranking out well-targeted, well-crafted static landing pages, and promoting them through email newsletters when it’s warranted.

The net result is the same kind of work, with a much higher return. It won’t show up in fancy case studies or popular blog posts, but it will make an impact on the bottom line.

Image used under Creative Commons, via Flickr.

Opinions expressed in the article are those of the guest author and not necessarily Search Engine Land.

Related Topics: All Things SEO Column | Channel: SEO


About The Author: is Co-Founder and CEO of Digital Due Diligence, a research firm that helps investors and acquirers understand the business models of SEO-, PPC-, and social media-dependent companies.

Connect with the author via: Email | Twitter


Get all the top search stories emailed daily!  


Other ways to share:

Read before commenting! We welcome constructive comments and allow any that meet our common sense criteria. This means being respectful and polite to others. It means providing helpful information that contributes to a story or discussion. It means leaving links only that substantially add further to a discussion. Comments using foul language, being disrespectful to others or otherwise violating what we believe are common sense standards of discussion will be deleted. Comments may also be removed if they are posted from anonymous accounts. You can read more about our comments policy here.
  • matt

    This is probably accurate for blogging in its original sense, as a source of viral awareness, social engagement, interaction etc, but it definitely doesn’t apply to another (arguable more valuable) benaefit: direct traffic generation, especially for long-tail keywords. We advise all our clients who have the capacity that they should be blogging. It generates traffic and the improved publishing frequency is a ranking signal. If our clients don’t have the time to write, they can get good material from external writers.

  • http://www.michael-martinez.com/ Michael Martinez

    Your position on category pages is vague and ambiguous. Most blogs benefit from allowing their category pages to be indexed. In fact, many people who complain about not receiving sitelinks or not being able to compete for the short keyword expressions that their categories are best arranged for NoIndex their category pages on the basis of bad “generic” SEO advice that category pages are somehow bad for SEO.

    That is absolute nonsense. It’s not the category pages that are causing the problems. It’s the naive approach to organizing and publishing a blog that creates a spaghetti network of category and tag pages that is the problem.

    The solution, however, is NOT to deindex the category pages. It’s to create a sensible, meaningful, sustainable structure and stick to that.

    Everyone someone in the SEO community throws out the glib (and utterly useless) advice to knock category pages out of the index, another blog dies an unnecessary and preventable death.

  • http://www.linkedin.com/in/marykaylofurno Mary Kay Lofurno

    I know of some companies that have forgone the blog by either using Facebook or their Twitter page as their platform. And its worked out great for them.

    It was a decision they made because of resources and it turned out fine for them. If it were me and I was a podiatrist, dentist, accountant, etc. I would consider that instead given the information mentioned above.

  • http://www.searchengineoptimizationjournal.com/ Nick Stamoulis

    I would add that a lot of blogs fail simply because the company doesn’t stick with it. Blogging is an incredibly long term process, and plenty of companies let their blogs fall to the wayside after a few months. They start out really excited and are churning out content, but then other things come up and blogging gets put on the back burner. The worst thing you could do is start a blog and then abandon it.

  • http://www.idslogic.com/ I.L.

    I do not completely agree with this criticism of blogs and the view they are a waste of time. Ever tried SEO Blogs? Write them, and put keywords in! I have seen them work!

  • http://www.lifeslittlefavors.com L.L.F.

    Does Google read the keywords in my blog as part of my website or does it see these two things differently? I’ve been using a blog thinking it will help me rank better for favors for weddings but after reading this article now I think I’m wasting my time. I do use a newsletter but never thought of posting it to my website. How should I go about doing that? Just copy and past the content to a new page?


Get Our News, Everywhere!

Daily Email:

Follow Search Engine Land on Twitter @sengineland Like Search Engine Land on Facebook Follow Search Engine Land on Google+ Get the Search Engine Land Feed Connect with Search Engine Land on LinkedIn Check out our Tumblr! See us on Pinterest


Click to watch SMX conference video

Join us at one of our SMX or MarTech events:

United States


Australia & China

Learn more about: SMX | MarTech

Free Daily Search News Recap!

SearchCap is a once-per-day newsletter update - sign up below and get the news delivered to you!



Search Engine Land Periodic Table of SEO Success Factors

Get Your Copy
Read The Full SEO Guide