Who’s Really Winning The Search War?

Every month, comScore releases its U.S. search engine market share reports, and these reports are widely shared by media outlets as the definitive source of search engine penetration.

Over the past couple of years, comScore reports have declared Google to be at a 65-68% market share, with most of the remainder divided up between Bing and Yahoo. Yet, these numbers don’t seem to align with what I’ve seen in multiple analytics reports, which place Google at closer to 85-90%.

Faced with two conflicting sets of search engine market share numbers, I wanted to understand whose search engine market share numbers were more accurate. To achieve this goal, I drafted a survey to capture a holistic view of users’ search engine behaviors to try to get the most accurate measure of their search engine loyalties.

Survey To Determine True Market Share

Users were queried about their awareness of search engines. Small search engines like Blekko and DuckDuckGo, as well as international ones like Yandex, Naver and Baidu, were included alongside the major engines (Google, Bing and Yahoo).

I asked users about their primary search engine and also how often they use each search engine. There were additional questions in the survey about the types of operating systems they use on their computer and questions about the technology of their mobile device.

Survey Methodology

I launched the survey using my employer’s SurveyMonkey Audience on a Friday, and by Monday I had achieved my statistically significant target of 500+ survey respondents in the United States.

A proper sample set is essential when conducting any survey that attempts to draw conclusions about people’s general behavior and preferences. And in this case, 350 is the minimum number of respondents I needed in order to capture a representative sample of all people in the U.S.

Additionally, in order for a sample to be valid, the respondents have to be chosen completely at random. SurveyMonkey Audience recruits its 4 million+ members from SurveyMonkey’s 40 million annual unique visitors, and members are not paid for their participation. Instead, they are rewarded for taking surveys with charitable donations, made on their behalf by SurveyMonkey.

When tested against much larger research projects, Audience data has been exactly in line with larger sample sizes. For example, an Audience survey with just 400 respondents about a new Lay’s potato chip flavor had the same results as a wider contest that had 3 million participants.

SurveyMonkey’s survey research team was also able to use SurveyMonkey Audience to accurately predict election results in both 2012 and 2013. With my sample size of 521 respondents drawn at random, my search engine market share rates should reliably mirror the actual reality. Here’s what I found.

Search Engine Usage Experience

First things first. I wanted to know which search engines users have tried:

• 98% have tried Google
• 83% have tried Yahoo
• 76% have tried Bing
• 54% have tried Ask
• 32% have tried Aol
• 5% have tried DuckDuckGo

What is interesting in these statistics is that part of Bing’s marketing push seems to be aimed at getting users to just give Bing a try. This is evident in campaigns like its BingItOn challenge, and even its current Bing Rewards program, which rewards users just for searching. It seems that the real challenge is not to get users to try Bing, but to keep them using it.

Primary Search Engine

On the question of which search engine respondents considered to be their primary search engine, Google was the big winner:

• Google – 80%
• Yahoo – 8%
• Bing – 6%

These figures seem far more in line with expected results based on my experiences with analytics reporting tools.

More Data

Here are some other interesting statistics that we learned in the survey:

Technology:

• More Google users use a Mac (24%) as their primary computer vs. Yahoo/Bing users (17%)
• Google users had the highest smartphone penetration (80%) vs. 58% for Yahoo and 65% for Bing

Frequency:

• 83% of Google users search on Google every day
• 78% of Bing users search on Bing every day
• 80% of Yahoo users search on Yahoo every day

Demographic information also seems to be a factor in a users search engine choice:

• Female primary Google users outnumber males (54/46%)
• For Bing and Yahoo, there are a greater number of male users
• The majority of Google users were younger than 45, while the opposite is true for Bing and Yahoo

Why Does Accurate Search Engine Market Share Even Matter?

As you can see, the search engine usage percentage numbers you see in your analytics might be more accurate than the figures reported by comScore. Accurate search engine market share should be a significant factor in how users allocate their time and budget.

If Bing/Yahoo’s market share is actually 29%, as comScore stated in its August 2014 report, shouldn’t PPC marketers spend at least a third of their time on Bing Campaigns?

Similarly for SEO, if Bing/Yahoo’s market share is so large, at least being aware of where a site ranks on Bing should be important.

There should be as much attention paid to the latest algorithm updates coming out from Microsoft as there is for the updates from Google.

ComScore Market Share Reports Vs. Analytics Reports

Judging from the social popularity of Search Engine Land posts on Bing updates vs. those from Google, it is apparent that marketers don’t seem to put much faith in the market share numbers reported by comScore.

This is likely because most marketers see markedly different search engine usage numbers in their own analytics software. The discrepancy between what web analytics packages show and what comScore reports declare could stem from how comScore develops its stats. The company generates its reach reports from a panel-based audience that installs tracking software on their computers and then marries this dataset with data that comes from a tracking beacon installed on millions of websites.

There can be obvious statistical challenges with using panelist data for measuring online activity; the data from the tracking tag should be providing actual user stats on most of the major websites on the internet. (For the curious, the comScore tracker is called Scorecard Research, and with the Ghostery Chrome plugin installed, you can see it on many of the websites you visit.)

Nonetheless, even with the comScore tracker on so many websites, comScore still needs to use weightings against demographics in order to generate full population assumptions. It is these calculations that might lead to some inconsistencies with actual search engine market share.

Take Away For Marketers

Knowing that Google’s market penetration is a lot closer to what most marketers believed already should justify continuing to focus the majority of time and budgets on Google. However, Google’s dominance is only a general average, and usage might be different for a particular website or audience.

An older target audience could very well be using Bing on a desktop to search online, while a younger audience is more likely to be using Google on a smartphone. Disregarding published market share reports and paying attention to a target audience’s individual search and technology preferences should really be the driver of how marketers spend their time and budget.

---

Opinions expressed in this article are those of the guest author and not necessarily Search Engine Land. Staff authors are listed here.

---