A Few Link Building Predictions For 2012

It’s prediction time again.

Before I dive into predictions for 2012, let’s take a look back at where I’ve been wrong and right over the years. I have a fairly good track record, and I like to take a few chances with these, rather than taking the easy way out with predictions like “links will still matter”.

Footer Links Get The Boot?

I was quite wrong about search engines devaluing all footer link networks. As easy as these are to spot, it baffles me that some sites can achieve high rankings via this spammy tactic. Check out this amazing expose blog post from Joost de Valk.

Prediction for 2012: This will be the year the footer link truly hits the ignore bucket. This tactic has been around since the early 90s with “free web counters” that sneakily linked to other sites. Then came WordPress themes, then site-wides, blogroll spam, footer links and many other tricks. Key word: tricks.

I am frankly amazed footer links have not been blown up. Like they should have been way back when school newspapers first used them like this below.  Sorry, I’m not telling you the school.

Paid links on a school newspaper web site

Directory Links Take A Dive

I was both right and wrong about general (non vertical) directory links losing all value. While some of the worst directories have finally died a welcome death, I have still witnessed sites improve rankings via submissions to weak no-name directories. It will stop someday, it just didn’t in 2011.

Hopefully, 2012 is the year the generic link directory to nowhere and everywhere stops having any effect at all. How can any algorithm take seriously a directory that nobody uses other than the people submitting links to them?

Sorry, Link-o-Matic is ficticious

The name of the game here is curated verticality. And it’s what I’ve been going after since the day I started in 1994.

Name me one single mass general directory that comes anywhere close to truly organizing and cataloging the Web. None of them can. Yahoo! couldn’t. DMOZ couldn’t. The Web’s very nature is distributed links pointing at expert content. Single source directories are antithetical to the nature of the web’s design.

Prediction for 2012: Watch for hundreds if not thousands of small highly curated and vetted resource lists to appear. In fact, they already do, and have for years.

I’m not going to give away the farm here, but for a recent project I gathered over 80 veterinary resource collections based at .orgs, coms, and .edus. These are small curated lists. And they matter. They matter more that you’d ever imagine.

Notice the link on the bottom right: Veterinary Product Vendor Sites. 

Which of the two directories would you rather be in?  Link-O-Matic above or this one below?

Facebook Brand Pages Build Likes & Links

I was wrong thinking any company with an existing and well trafficked website could forgo having a Facebook page.

While not an absolute necessity for every site, (are enough people really going to become fans of the Preperation H Hemmoroid Treatment Facebook page to matter?) the sheer mass and potential matriculation across the Facebook links space make it a worthwhile alternative mode to reach customers.  At least for most brands it does.

Prediction for 2012:  Dare I say it, every brand not currently on Facebook will be by the end of 2012.

Please Like Us - We Stop Itching!

Twitter Link Cred

I was right about Twitter having a far smaller effect on organic search rank that most claimed it would. Tweeted links have yet prove to me that their rank has improved due to being tweeted. Tweets are good for quick drive by traffic and that’s about it.

The only Twitter impact I see in organic results is people with Twitter credibility will see their twitter profile rank quite high. I was a reluctant Twitter user several years ago, but I can’t argue with the fact that my Twitter profile ranks at position 4 for a search on my name, and I’ve done nothing other than be cautous about who I follow and what I tweet.

My Twitter profile Ranks #4

Prediction for 2012: People will stop chasing followers and work on sculpting a more authoritative Twitter profile. What this means is instead of following 17,000 people and having 17,000 followers, people will realize that to have any influence at all, you need have more followers than you follow, and you need to tweet about things other than how wonderful your most recent column was. Share the good, curate the helpful, and the followers will come.

Anchor Text Gets Devalued

I was right about anchor text being devalued. This was never a reliable signal, because it was too SEO centric a signal and too easily gamed. You’ve heard me say before, in 17+ years of requesting links, I’ve never once asked for anchor text.

The most trustworthy content on the Web is not going to give over editorial rights to you so you can anchor your way up the Google ladder. We are all the Hemingway’s of our own content, so don’t tell me how to link to you.

The engines more than likely did not realize just how far people would go to try and manipulate anchor text, but the ironic thing about this is the more you try to manipulate your anchor text, the more you create a backlink profile that looks suspicious when compared to the mass of historical anchor text data the engines have to study.

Prediction for 2012: Services like these below slowly but surely start to vanish.

Two Final Predictions

First, people will discover the fantastic and free linking data available from blekko. It’s incredible.

Second, people will realize the futility of relying on search engines for all their traffic, and put more effort into link marketing tactics and strategies that have nothing to do with search results, like this.

Don’t laugh, their last client’s QR code baked cookies resulted in a 40% scan and install rate for a mobile app. Forty percent. Via an edible baked cookie with a QR code on the icing.  And yes, it was my idea and it had nothing to do with search engines. Here’s one they baked for me:

Baked Cookie with QR Code

Sometimes us early adopters who have been around a while can see the forest for the trees. Have a great 2012!

Opinions expressed in the article are those of the guest author and not necessarily Search Engine Land.

Related Topics: Channel: SEO | Link Week Column


About The Author: has been creating linking strategies for clients since 1994. Eric publishes the strategic linking advice newsletter LinkMoses Private, and provides linking services, training and consulting via EricWard.com.

Connect with the author via: Email | Twitter | Google+ | LinkedIn


Get all the top search stories emailed daily!  


Other ways to share:

Read before commenting! We welcome constructive comments and allow any that meet our common sense criteria. This means being respectful and polite to others. It means providing helpful information that contributes to a story or discussion. It means leaving links only that substantially add further to a discussion. Comments using foul language, being disrespectful to others or otherwise violating what we believe are common sense standards of discussion will be deleted. Comments may also be removed if they are posted from anonymous accounts. You can read more about our comments policy here.
  • http://www.infatex.com Mikhail Tuknov

    Thanks for sharing your predictions Eric!

  • http://www.linkbuildr.com L.T.

    Great post Eric and thanks for the tip on Yoast’s post on Godaddy…crazy interesting and everyone loves a good outing. I still remember when one of the spam engineer’s stated that Google will be “drastically changing the way they view links” in the near future, and I’m still waiting. I’m waiting for more of a change on anchor text weight as it is still out of hand.

  • W.M.

    Thanks for sharing Eric !

  • https://www.nouvoseo.co.il N.S.

    great mart tips! i really liked the QR Cookies – very creative.

  • http://francoispainchaud.com Francois Painchaud

    Good post, but most of these predictions could have been in the “predictions for 2011″, i.e. directory links, anchor texts, footer links. Cheers

  • http://www.facebook.com/SimpleInternetStrategies Eunice Coughlin

    Great predictions. I can’t believe people are still using directories as a back-linking technique. The one about anchor text is kind of shocking but it makes sense, anything that can be gamed should be out!

  • http://about.me/joy joy larkin

    Eric – As for Twitter links, I’ve actually had the opposite experience – especially for large database driven sites.

    The boost to Tweeted links isn’t the Twitter Web site, it’s the other sites online where Tweeted links are syndicated.

  • http://about.me/mmhemani Moosa Hemani

    Nice predictions but i might not agree with all of them… like you said the Anchor link has been devalued by search engine.. in my opinion this is not the case, i mean i do agree with the fact that anchor link value has been degraded in 2011 but saying that they have been kicked out completely or devalued will not be a correct statement in my opinion!

  • http://www.seochemist.com Oli

    You might want to do a little more research in to the exact devaluation of anchor text.

    I also think the part “Then came WordPress themes” is incorrect to some degree. If a theme creator creates a beautiful theme and thousands of people use it, they deserve the links. Of course if you are talking about the poor quality, minor changes, sold links slapped on teh bottom approach, yes that is way to spammy.


    I doubt footer links will be completely devalued. Even though it is generally a suspicious place to put an external link, it is still used by many to give editorial, meaningful credit in a way that is not entirely centred around manipulating search.

    I think directory links have taken a hit already this year, not as powerful as they once were that is for sure.

    I agree about people looking for ways to link in terms of what is more likely to give traffic over pinning all hopes on organic search results. Something i have been trying, trouble is certain sectors are a bit niche and search engines have the monopoly at the moment.

  • http://www.cyber-key.com/SocialSEO/ mjtaylor

    I, too, read Yoast’s interesting post. But I don’t agree that footer links will bite the dust this year. They are too valid as links – if you have captured my imagination and I have read through to the end of a page, it makes sense to offer me footer navigation that will keep me on the site. That makes those links, IMO, as valuable as any – it not a higher quality signal than other nav links. Indeed if they get clicked it’s a more reliable signal that the visitor actually read something of interest than the use of a left or right hand navigation menu.

    I do love your idea of more ‘vetted” lists – and I have been surprised that more folks haven’t jumped on the SEO tools from blekko! Great resource!

  • http://www.zhoupingseo.com/ zhou ping


    So could yo provide some effective link building tips?

    Zhou Ping

  • Andrei Cosmin

    Ok, social networks are the next big sh*t in SEO. So what? We can rig that game too.


Get Our News, Everywhere!

Daily Email:

Follow Search Engine Land on Twitter @sengineland Like Search Engine Land on Facebook Follow Search Engine Land on Google+ Get the Search Engine Land Feed Connect with Search Engine Land on LinkedIn Check out our Tumblr! See us on Pinterest


Click to watch SMX conference video

Join us at one of our SMX or MarTech events:

United States


Australia & China

Learn more about: SMX | MarTech

Free Daily Search News Recap!

SearchCap is a once-per-day newsletter update - sign up below and get the news delivered to you!



Search Engine Land Periodic Table of SEO Success Factors

Get Your Copy
Read The Full SEO Guide