Cuil Fast Test – Relevancy Isn’t A Google Killer
Now that Cuil is
live, I wanted to do a few fast queries to get a sense of how it seems
to stack up against Google. With the huge caveat that nine queries are far
from letting anyone conclude anything, I still didn’t come away with a sense
that Cuil has Google-beating relevancy. Instead, it has some flaws though, admittedly, is
better than many start-up search engines appear out of the box. Queries I
miserable failure: Cuil has suggested it wouldn’t be vulnerable to
the Googlebomb that
made President George W. Bush rank at the top of Google for years for
this phrase. Not so. Bush
shows up at
number two (reading right to left).
cars: Cuil said they’d feature a variety of subjects for a query.
So for [cars], I’m wanting to see pages for both automobiles and the movie
"Cars," as I get with
Google. This doesn’t happen.
Indeed, the movie doesn’t even appear as a related category to explore.
jaguar: Another good query for testing if a variety of subjects
come up, as jaguar can refer to the game console, the car or the animal
(among other things).
Cuil gives me all three,
while Google misses the gaming system. But Cuil puts me off with this
description for the "Save The Jaguars" page:
The Google Mobile Friendly Update launches tomorrow, a day that many including ourselves here at Search Engine Land are calling "Mobilegeddon." We first learned of Google's plan to release a new algorithm designed to reward mobile-friendly web pages back in February. It's unprecedented for...
[caption id="attachment_218588" align="aligncenter" width="800"] Image created using Canva.com and used with permission.[/caption] Last month, Pauline Jakober wrote a great column about some of the awesome ways to use the AdWords Dimensions tab to improve account performance. That post inspired me to...
When I was growing up, my parents bought me every Nancy Drew book that existed. I loved the mysteries, the characters, and of course the fact that Nancy was an independent woman -- something that I aspired to be. Of course,...
Have you ever wondered why 404s, rel=canonicals, noindex, nofollow, and robots.txt work the way they do? Or have you never been clear on quite how they do all work? To help you understand, here is a very basic interpretation of...
For many of us, analyzing our AdWords data starts with downloading a massive .CSV file into Excel and running various calculations and building charts. After that, we turn into fortune tellers, trying to read the analytical tea leaves of our data and predict what...
Call it mobilegeddon,mobilepocalyse, mobocalypse or mopocalypse, Google's big update on April 21 that will reward mobile-friendly pages is coming. If you're not mobile-friendly, you could find some ranking drops. How to prepare? The folks at Nine Hertz have created an infographic...
If you've checked out the new call-only campaigns in AdWords, you've probably noticed the phone verification piece to prove the phone number is associated with the business that's advertising. Google has announced that verification will also be rolling out to...
Matt Cutts, Google's currently on leave head of spam, has revealed his April Fools prank for 2015, it is named AutoSEO hosted at seo.ninja. AutoSEO is a free open source tool that helps webmasters handle the task of SEO automatically. What...
At last month's SMX West conference, it was clear that the Pigeon Update has caused a huge shift in the local search world. There were hardly any questions about citations this year -- most of the questions related to site content...
What's more important than writing great content? Making sure people can find it! While search engine algorithms are getting better at discovering and ranking new content on the web, there are still a lot of things you can do to influence that process....
Google's mobile-friendly ranking algorithm that is launching on April 21st will be on a page-by-page and real-time basis but how long will it take to roll out and how do you know if your page qualifies to benefit from it? Since...
There are some features in AdWords you just can't live without when managing a PPC account -- and the "Dimensions" tab is one of them. In fact, I polled my team the other day, and they unanimously cited the Dimensions...
In the early days of search engines, I wasn't much of a believer in XML sitemaps. But over time, I began to see first hand how they can benefit websites. XML sitemaps serve as a way to communicate directly with the search...
There is no such thing as a bad keyword, there are only bad bids. While this is a bit of an overstatement, there is a nugget of truth to it. Naturally, a strategy of bidding on irrelevant keywords will hurt your...
Google's latest blog post on the Webmaster Central blog is encouraging webmasters to adopt and implement autocomplete on web forms on your mobile web sites. Google's Mathieu Perreault from the Chrome team and Zineb Ait Bahajji from the Webmaster Trends team...
Google penalties can be a major setback, but regardless of why your site gets hit, it’s vital that you take quick and aggressive action to recover your organic search rankings. If your site has been penalized, don’t panic! With the right...
[caption id="attachment_216792" align="aligncenter" width="800"] Photo by Tim Ash[/caption] Last week, I spent three solid days camped out in the PPC marketing and mobile tracks at SMX West 2015. Believe it or not, I don’t just run away to sunny California to escape...
Last month, we shared an AdWords Script to let you test anything and received countless examples of people using this creatively for PPC success. Based on your comments and feedback, we're now sharing version 2, which is even better! The script has...
As SEOs, we've all heard for several years that we need to integrate structured data into our websites. At SMX 2015, the speakers at "The Next Generation of Structured Data: Taking Markup To The Next Level" provided compelling new ways to use...
Benchmarks have always been a hot topic in the world of PPC measurement. After all, it's often left up to the marketer to choose the benchmarks that will be used to evaluate their performance. In some respects, it’s like letting...
[conservation] [adopt a jaguar] [news] [resources]
That’s easily fixed, but descriptions are important for generated
relevancy among searchers. I’m also not certain why schrodinger.com comes up
in the top results.
viagra: Seeing URLs for utahpheasantsociety.org (which redirects
to a Viagra selling site) or a page called "EuroDNS & Domain Name Parking
Page" for Cuil’s
results are off-putting, but they do have the official site as well as
the FDA. Of course, Google has both, and with the FDA it points right at the
FDA’s page on Viagra.
Getting patents.cos.com first, then being told that patent search is no
longer available there and to visit the US Patent Office, is disappointing.
Getting the US Patent office listed fifth is also disappointing. Getting the
Wikipedia Page on the Google Patents service, rather than patents in
general, yet another disappointment. Google lists the US Patent office first
and the general Wikipedia page on patents third.
new york: Well,
getting only three results tells me something’s just not right with Cuil
danny sullivan: Ego search time! Ego searches are a terrible way
for anyone but an individual to usually measure relevancy, but they’re often
done and search engines are assessed individually on them. For me, it’s all me!
The race car driver isn’t to be found! He gets one listing on Google.) Cuil
old place I used to write at (Search Engine Watch) first, rather than Search
Engine Land (as
Google does — the old place comes up third). My personal blog at
daggle.com isn’t listed — Google has it. Both have my Wikipedia page.
Google has my Twitter page and my main page from my consulting web site.
annie williams watercolour: One of my favorite artists; in the
past I’ve found virtually little about her on the web. This search
gives me 14 results from Cuil, though only 7 are listed. Her Wikipedia
page doesn’t come up, probably because it spells "water colour" as two words.
Google, supposedly less comprehensive, gives me 777,000 matches! OK, skip
the numbers — something’s probably not right with Cuil’s counting. Still,
Google gets me her Wikipedia page plus a BBC Radio 4 interview — something
doesn’t have at all.
17 palms oasis: A cool place in California’s Anza Borrego dessert
where people leave notes to each other in a diary box under one of the
palms. Cuil’s first page of results all look very on-target and relevant.
Google’s are also good, though the last about Kauai isn’t on the main
subject I had in mind.
Let me end with a caveat again. To measure relevancy, you want to run a
battery of tests on a variety of different subjects. Lots and lots of them,
and have a number of people share their own subjective experiences. My
from 2002, "In Search Of The Relevancy Figure," goes into depth about this.
Despite my call then and my 2005
"Screw Size! I Dare Google & Yahoo To Report On Relevancy," we still lack
this type of metric or testing body. As a result, a different set results
could show Cuil (or another search engine) as more relevant than Google —
or not. But the lack of such testing means that no one (not even Google) can
authoritatively claim that title.
(Some images used under license from Shutterstock.com.)
Get the best search news, tips and resources, delivered each day.