4 Reasons The Social Link Graph Will Have To Improve

Those who are responsible for creating awareness of content take great pleasure seeing a shared link riding the waves across Twitter, Facebook, G+, or anywhere else the sharer wants to push it.  And rightfully so. It is rewarding to see your efforts succeed and click traffic increase.

Weighing Social Graph Signals in SearchBut from a search results standpoint, there are aspects to the social link graph that make the playing field uneven and out of balance.

The search engines have to know this, and hopefully are adapting and accounting for it before rewarding a site with higher search rank due to social signals.

There are several bothersome aspects to the social link graph and its impact on search results that merit discussion. Here are a few examples.

1.  Product Effectiveness Versus Human Nature

Take a look at the Facebook page for Pepsi, and you find close to 8 million Likes. Coca-Cola’s page has 40 million Likes.

To what extent does this matter with regards to search rank? To what extent does it matter at all? These are easy brands to like, so of course they will attract millions of likes.

But what if you have the misfortune to be the brand manager for Preparation H? Or RID head lice treatment? Notice on their main websites they don’t even bother with social media buttons.

It’s like they already know it’s futile. No parent is going to let their entire facebook friend lists or G+ circles know their kid has head lice. In an ironic twist, is it possible that the more important a product is to solving a real problem, the less likely that product is to ever catch a social media wave?

How about substance abuse facilities? Ready to tell the world you finally kicked that crack habit? Like that and share that story with all your friends and business associates on LinkedIn.

So the reality then is we can’t all be Skittles (21 million likes, 28k followers). We are what we are. If you sell grain elevators in Iowa, your Twitter feed is going to be very lonely.

The obvious question: how does the algorithm account for a product’s social potential across subject areas? You can’t penalize a site because it’s boring. Grain elevators are boring. But someone has to rank first, with or without a Facebook or G+ page.

2.  Inclusion & Location Of Share Functionality

The decision as to where you place those little buttons on your page can significantly impact whether they get clicked or not, yet is often quite arbitrary, or forced into a specific spot due to design issues. I see many sites with long content pages that include the social click tiles at the very end of the article.  That’s it.

But what if the article was absolutely awesome and I learned what I needed to know in the first paragraph and didn’t scroll any further? I never saw those social buttons. Impulse social click opportunity lost.

Example of Social Share buttons on Digital Highrise

I know people can share content without their being any on-page buttons, but really, what percentage of the Web using population has added a “Tweet this” button to their browser toolbar? That number is likely very low.

So the reality is, your site’s ability to attract its maximum social share potential could be determined not by the quality of your content, but by your placement of the share function.

3.  Intent Of Searcher

Your spouse is having some health issues and your researching it online. You find what you were looking for. His symptoms indicate potential problems. You print it out for him.

At that moment, you aren’t in share-with-the-world mode, no matter how stupendous the content was. No matter how many buttons the page has or where they are placed, you are not going to hop over to your facebook page and update your status to “Just found what I needed to help Jim with his ulcerative colitis!”

So the reality is that the choice to share or not is is also driven by the purpose the user of the site or search engine at that moment.  Quality of content had nothing to do with it.

4.  Incentivized Social Activity

“Like us on Facebook and receive 5% off your purchase”. Really? How does Mr. Algorithm factor in incentivized social signals?  “Help us reach 100,000 followers!”

I’m not going to link to any of the many sites and brands that have a bounty or rewards based social strategy, but being honest here, that’s smart, makes perfect sense, and is a great use of social media for branding and click traffic.

But from a search perspective, doesn’t it muddy the water for the algorithm when one company is paying for followers or fans, and another company isn’t?

So the reality is we cannot say with certainty how the the social activity surrounding any brand came to be.

These are just a few issues worth discussing. There are many others. The social graph is in its infancy and it’s not going away. Google already shows 180,000 results for the phrase “social media expert”.  Let’s all hope the collective wisdom on both sides of the social media and SEO equation can find  balance.

Opinions expressed in the article are those of the guest author and not necessarily Search Engine Land.

Related Topics: Channel: SEO | Link Week Column


About The Author: has been creating linking strategies for clients since 1994. Eric publishes the strategic linking advice newsletter LinkMoses Private, and provides linking services, training and consulting via EricWard.com.

Connect with the author via: Email | Twitter | Google+ | LinkedIn


Get all the top search stories emailed daily!  


Other ways to share:

Read before commenting! We welcome constructive comments and allow any that meet our common sense criteria. This means being respectful and polite to others. It means providing helpful information that contributes to a story or discussion. It means leaving links only that substantially add further to a discussion. Comments using foul language, being disrespectful to others or otherwise violating what we believe are common sense standards of discussion will be deleted. Comments may also be removed if they are posted from anonymous accounts. You can read more about our comments policy here.
  • http://www.davidfricks.com/blog/ David Fricks

    All good points.

  • http://www.echelonseo.com Brent Carnduff

    Saw someone selling +1s for G+ today – they have to be able to account for that possibility as well.

  • http://www.ericward.com Eric Ward

    Go to google and do this search

    Buy google plus

    The first result sells 500 Google +1′s for $45. And there are already over 11million exact match results doing something similar. I’m sure sooner or later a footprint is left by these fake accounts, but this is another rason why social serps have a long way to go.

  • http://www.metronet.no Trond Lyngbø

    In the same way that buying links is described as Black Hat SEO today, I am convinced that the purchase of Google +1 votes, Facebook Likes and so on will end up in the same category tomorrow.

    ‘SEO spammers’ are bombing social search on the ground, and I think Google will have difficulty in distinguishing real from fake “votes”.

    A few weeks ago I wrote a blog post (pending) on the same topic here on Search Engine Land, and I look forward to having a discussion around this.

    Is “social search” dead on arrival? Or on life support? (and can it still be resuscitated?)

    I think it is time to ask critical questions.

    Great blog post, Eric!

    Kind regards,


  • Simon Haestoe

    Love the, very common sense, tip about having the buttons high up. Great:). http://www.simonhaestoe.com


Get Our News, Everywhere!

Daily Email:

Follow Search Engine Land on Twitter @sengineland Like Search Engine Land on Facebook Follow Search Engine Land on Google+ Get the Search Engine Land Feed Connect with Search Engine Land on LinkedIn Check out our Tumblr! See us on Pinterest


Click to watch SMX conference video

Join us at one of our SMX or MarTech events:

United States


Australia & China

Learn more about: SMX | MarTech

Free Daily Search News Recap!

SearchCap is a once-per-day newsletter update - sign up below and get the news delivered to you!



Search Engine Land Periodic Table of SEO Success Factors

Get Your Copy
Read The Full SEO Guide