Claude visibility may depend heavily on Brave Search rankings, new data suggests
Claude frequently pulls from Brave Search results, with ranking, recency, and comparison prompts triggering searches most often.
Claude may be more directly tied to Brave Search rankings than other AI answer engines, according to information Jonathan Clark shared on LinkedIn from a Zero Click by Profound session.
Clark, managing partner at Moving Traffic Media, said the session’s key takeaway was that Claude “doesn’t re-rank search results” and instead appears to use Brave’s top 10 results directly in its answers.
Claude searched less often. Claude used web search in 36.6% of prompts, compared with about 90% for ChatGPT, according to Clark.
- Claude was most likely to search when prompts signaled freshness, rankings, location, or comparison intent. Recency-focused prompts such as “best XYZ” triggered search 81% of the time, while ranking-focused prompts triggered search 67% of the time.
- Location-focused prompts triggered search 55% of the time, while comparison prompts such as “X vs. Y” triggered search 51% of the time.
Brave rankings carried weight. Claude’s citations overlapped with ChatGPT’s in only 8% of cases when responding to the same prompts, according to Clark.
- Claude’s results had much higher overlap with Google rankings, at 64%. This suggests that Google SEO efforts may carry over more readily to Claude than strategies focused specifically on improving visibility in ChatGPT, according to Clark.
- The finding also increased the importance of Brave rank tracking. Clark said Claude uses Brave, and that ranking well in Brave gives us “something we can monitor and correlate to data.”
Some prompts stayed in memory. Prompts such as “how does,” “what is,” and “steps to” were less likely to trigger Claude to search the web. When Claude doesn’t search, it can’t cite web pages. Claude searched most often for prompts containing terms such as “best,” “top,” “near me,” and comparison-style queries, according to Clark.
Years showed up often. Clark also noted two patterns that could make Claude easier to test:
- Claude’s query fan-outs were nearly deterministic, producing the same fan-out 65% of the time across users.
- The fan-outs often included years.
- That means page titles with current-year signals may have an advantage in Claude-triggered searches, especially for ranking and freshness-driven prompts.
Why we care. Claude visibility appears to depend more heavily on ranking in the search results Claude uses. Clark’s takeaway was that Claude may be one of the most optimizable AI answer engines today because its search behavior appears more consistent and more closely tied to observable search rankings.
Search Engine Land is owned by Semrush. We remain committed to providing high-quality coverage of marketing topics. Unless otherwise noted, this page’s content was written by either an employee or a paid contractor of Semrush Inc.
About the Author
