Will Mobile Apps Be Google’s Undoing? (Hint: No)
The New York Times offers an interesting story about Google and the competitive landscape of mobile. The headline is “As Web Search Goes Mobile, Competitors Chip at Google’s Lead.” The central idea of the article is that while Google is used on the PC equally to discover information and to navigate to specific sites, on smartphones […]
The New York Times offers an interesting story about Google and the competitive landscape of mobile. The headline is “As Web Search Goes Mobile, Competitors Chip at Google’s Lead.” The central idea of the article is that while Google is used on the PC equally to discover information and to navigate to specific sites, on smartphones people go directly to apps such as Amazon, Kayak or Yelp.
As a basic matter, that’s accurate. However, quoting Danny Sullivan, the story also acknowledges that there’s still a great deal of mobile search activity, which is dominated by Google. Indeed, according to StatCounter, Google’s global mobile search market share is roughly 95 percent.
Yet, we also know that “four out of five minutes” spent on mobile devices are spent with apps (per comScore). And, Nielsen said previously that roughly 80 percent of mobile time is with apps rather than the browser.
Yesterday, Flurry Analytics published findings based on five years of smartphone traffic data. The company affirmed that the majority of time spent is with apps. Echoing the Nielsen figure, Flurry said that 80 percent of mobile consumer time is on apps. And Facebook is the single dominant mobile app.
This all supports the premise of the NY Times’ piece: there’s different user behavior in mobile and apps to grab some query volume that might otherwise go to Google in a PC context. However, as I argued earlier this year, Google is adapting quickly and accommodating mobile user interests. In more and more cases it offers “answers” and fewer Web links, which marginalizes many publishers.
Even though Google has lost some traffic to apps, people are still using search in mobile (and it’s more valuable than PC search to marketers). Google controls the homescreen of most Android devices with its prominent search box, while mobile Safari drives a great deal of default Google search volume on iOS. In addition, Google has the number-one local search app in the form of Google Maps.
With Enhanced (AdWords) Campaigns, the company has moved aggressively to close the monetization gap between PC CPCs and mobile clicks — cleverly under the umbrella of simplification.
Having said that, Google does face a somewhat more competitive environment in mobile from Apple/Siri, Facebook (potentially) and the fragmented universe of apps, as the NY Times argues. Yet, mobile consumers clearly use search — especially on tablets — as a primary tool. It’s just that their behavior on smartphones, in particular, is more nuanced, complex and perhaps “democratic” than on the PC.
Far from being undone by mobile, Google remains dominant in many ways, including mobile advertising revenue. Yet, many publishers, through mobile apps, have also escaped the “Google tax” or “Google toll” (as it is sometimes called) and what many perceive to be the infuriating capriciousness of the Google algorithm.